Melinda Liu
|
Dec 1, 2007 04:57 PM
What do the Beijing Games have to do with this week’s diplomatic
hissy-fit between Chinese and European Union senior officials over
product safety? Following months of export scandals and Western recalls
of flawed Chinese goods, the Beijing Olympics media center laid on a
Nov. 12 press visit to a string of chicken-processing, pig-butchering
and product-inspection facilities to emphasize the city’s commitment to
food safety.
Among other things we saw neat assembly lines of pig carcasses being
sawed, sliced and cut into bits. While graphic, the scenes bore little
resemblance to how we imagine most meat gets processed in China,
evoking the Chicago abattoirs of Upton Sinclair’s time. Chinese factory
officials bent over backwards to assure us their high standards
guaranteed food safety for ALL Beijing citizens, not just visiting
Olympians. That was to deflate rumors that secret pig-raising centers
had been established to guaranteed hormone-free “pampered” pork for
Olympic athletes – gossip which blogger Andrew Lih dubbed “the Olympic
pig conspiracy.”
The timing of that media event seemed quite the coincidence when,
this past week, Beijing opened a big international food-safety
conference. That’s when the high-level catfight erupted. First EU Trade
Commissioner Peter Mandelson tore into Chinese authorities for their
record of unsafe exports and “tidal wave” of counterfeits. “During the
summer some Chinese officials pointed out that less than 1 percent of
China’s exports to Europe had alleged health risks,” he declared, “But
Europe imports half a billion euros worth of goods from China daily, so
even 1 percent is not acceptable.”
Mandelson’s rant was “unfair” and “inappropriate for today’s
occasion”, maintained Wei Chuanzhong, deputy director of China’s
General Administration of Quality Supervision, Inspection and
Quarantine (one of the organizations that featured during our little
press trip, by the way). Chinese vice premier Wu Yi-- Beijing’s top
trade official, nicknamed the “Iron Lady” -- was even more miffed. She
declared herself “extremely unhappy” with Mandelson’s remarks and
defended China’s efforts to improve quality control and crack down on
pirated goods.
Later that same day, Mandelson riposted that Wu should not have
taken exception to his statement that four-fifths of the counterfeit
items pouring over Europe’s borders originate in China. “We must seek
truth from facts,” he said, citing a phrase identified with Beijing’s
late strongman Deng Xiaoping.
What exactly are the facts surrounding China’s food-safety record,
and why are Western officials so concerned? Here’s an interview my
colleague Han Songmei conducted with Dr Roger Skinner, who’s
investigated China’s food safety system as a consultant for the World
Health Organization. The London-based specialist is lead author of a
report on suggested reforms that was sponsored by China’s State Food
and Drug Administration (SFDA), the World Health Organization and the
Asian Development Bank. Skinner was remarkably candid; check out these
excerpts:
More