Larry Kaplow
|
Oct 20, 2008 04:07 PM
Perhaps the most famous of Hammurabi's legal codes was the tooth
thing. Written in Mesopotamia about 2,700 years ago, it read, roughly,
"If a man has knocked out the tooth of a man of the same rank, they
shall knock out his tooth." There was the eye-for-an-eye clause, of
course, and then many more intricate instructions. He covered domestic
problems: "If the wife of a man has been caught while lying with
another man, they shall bind them and throw them into the water. If the
husband wishes to spare his wife then the king in turn may spare his
subject." And lengthy treatments were made on how to take care of
another man's property. If you rent his ox and kill it, you have to
give him a new ox (same with slaves). And there were some tough rules
for contractors. If you built a house so poorly that it collapsed and
killed the owner's son, then your son had to be put to death.
What to do about the damage at the Iraq National Museum has never
been so clear cut. Ever since it was looted in the anarchy after the
United States 2003 invasion, it has been the subject of controversy
over how many thousands of pieces were taken and how to get them back
as they're sold around the world and general confusion. It continued as
a symbol of America's haphazard occupation years later as top-flight
Iraqi archeologists fled under threat. While experts from the United
States and other countries have made efforts to aid Iraq's struggling
antiquities institutions, Iraqi bureaucracy and corruption slowed the
work and confounded the outsiders. Some stolen pieces were found and
plastered back together but rebuilding an entire archeological
establishment is a lot more complicated. The Iraq National Museum still
has not been able to open for the public. It lacks air conditioning,
regular electricity, security systems and safe surroundings.
But the slow road to recovery advanced a step today when U.S. and
Iraqi officials met in the museum's auditorium to announce a $14
million aid program. The relatively modest sum compared to the billions
poured into the country monthly for everything from generators to
supplying the Iraqi army with weapons is the largest gift received by
the museum so far, according to director Amira Edan al-Dahab. Al-Dahab
called today the "happiest" day the museum has ever seen. Asked later
about the saddest day, she said, "the looting, of course."
The two-year grant, which was announced by First Lady Laura Bush in
Washington last week, is for refurbishing the museum complex, sending
Iraqi archeologists to train in the United States and opening a
conservation center in the northern city of Irbil. Stony Brook
University in New York and the University of Chicago are two premier
archeological brain trusts involved in the project and, indeed, have
been working since the war began to protect Iraq's antiquities.
But the Baghdad ceremony was also another reminder of the remaining problems, as Newsweek wrote about in February.
The event was held in the small auditorium, where there was no air
conditioning and the room was lit by flood lights tacked to the walls
while the main lighting stayed dark. The museum is a campus of
buildings where hundreds of workers study artifacts from the country's
more than 12,000 historic sites. All but a few of the sites are
unprotected and open to continued raiding. To be sure, the war did not
bring all the havoc. The sites were also regularly pillaged as Saddam
Hussein's control slipped throughout the 1990s and corrupt officials
sent some antiquities to the black market. Meanwhile today's government
provides too little money to protect the country's vast network of
ancient sites. Historical texts are being lost for sure as smugglers
zero toss them aside in search of flashier objects.
An Italian archeological institute has led the renovation of two
museum galleries. They are closed to the public but NEWSWEEK has toured
them in the past. One is a spectacular collection of large statues and
wall-sized stone relief tablets, more than 2,000 years old and telling
stories or peace treaties and military offensives. Another gallery
highlights stone and woodwork from early Islam. The rest of the dozen
or so galleries are in disarray. The roof leaks and U.S. military
project to repair it has been held up in a bureaucratic battle over
money.
Mesopotamian history is hard to match. Writing was invented here
with the wedge-shaped cuneiform impressions in clay. The first urban
centers developed here. In a building with artifacts 6,000 years old,
the speakers from the relatively nascent United States took pains to
show that they value heritage. U.S. Ambassador Ryan Crocker called the
aid program an "investment" in the world's heritage and "10,000 years
of human history." But all that history is a heavy burden to carry.
More