Sharon Begley
|
Jul 5, 2007 12:52 PM
“Omigod I am so glad you’re here! I tried to text you and had no
service, but I so wanted to ask if you were okay after what you texted
me before because I was so worried, I mean, I had no idea what was up
with you . . ."
"Yo"
If you had to guess which greeting came from a male and which from a
female, you undoubtedly identified the first as uttered by a girl and
the latter by a boy. Not so fast.
For 15 years the claim has been floating around that females talk
more than men, with last year’s popular book “The Female Brain,” by
neuropsychiatrist Louann Brizendine, asserting that women use 20,000
words per day while men manage to spit out a mere 7,000. In reality,
these estimates are based on little-to-no data. One study that tried to
be systematic gave manual tape recorders to 153 volunteers in Britain,
and estimated that women speak 8,805 words per day and men, 6,073. But
the researchers had no say in whether the volunteers turned off the
recorders, or even knew when they did so, making it possible that the
verbal gap reflected men’s reluctance to be recorded.
Researchers at The University of Texas at Austin have done better.
For eight years James Pennebaker and colleagues gave volunteers
electronically activated digital recorders. The devices were programmed
to record for 30 seconds every 12.5 minutes, night and day, for two to
10 days. The participants neither knew when the device was on nor could
activate or deactivate it manually. Analyzing the transcripts of 396
students in the U.S. and Mexico, the scientists find that women speak
about 16,215 words per day and men about 15,669, they report in
tomorrow’s issue of the journal Science, a difference that was
statistically insignificant.
More