N'Gai Croal
|
Apr 20, 2007 02:06 PM
With our first Team Assault series of Q&As
behind us, the Level Up staff can now turn its attention to other news.
We first considered weighing in on the Virginia Tech shootings on
Monday, before any link whatsoever to videogames had been made--Florida
attorney and notorious videogame opponent Jack Thompson's
rush for the cameras on Fox News notwithstanding--with a piece about
the industry battening down its hatches and bracing for the inevitable
"He played [Insert Game Here]" stories that would be sure to emerge.
After all, a man of Cho Seung-***'s age is far more likely than not to
play videogames; it would be like saying that he watched TV or listened
to music, but that wouldn't prevent hordes of pundits, many of whom
don't play games, from opining that [Insert Game Here] caused Cho to
murder his fellow students and instructors.
Then the Washington Post, NEWSWEEK's sister company, put up an online story and blog post reporting that
"several Korean youths who knew Cho Seung *** from his high school days
said he was a fan of violent video games, particularly Counterstrike
[sic], a hugely popular online game published by Microsoft, in which
players join terrorism or counterterrorism groups and try to shoot each
other using all types of guns." Our editors were now interested the
reactions of developer and publisher of Counter-Strike,
so we reached out to them for comment. Once again, the news overtook
our reporting speed. A publicist at Microsoft, which published the Xbox
version of Counter-Strike, informed us that the Washington Post had removed the reference to Counter-Strike from the print and online versions
of the piece. We consulted with our editors once more, and were told to
stand down on this angle unless we had confirmation that Cho played the
game.
In hindsight, we're glad that we didn't weigh in on the
Virginia Tech massacre sooner because we're not convinced that we had
anything particularly interesting to say. Instead, we turned to some
people who did. NEWSWEEK senior writer Peg Tyre, whose book "The
Trouble With Boys," will be published by Crown in September 2008,
wrote:
Some experts say when we push that kind of zero tolerance for violence
on children we are getting it exactly wrong. Children, and particularly
boys, are acutely sensitive to the violence around them. They play out
violent themes to help relieve themselves of the natural fear and
confusion they feel. Jane Katch, a longtime kindergarten teacher and
author of "Under Dead Men's Skin: Discovering the Meaning of Children's
Violent Play" (Beacon Press), says these outlets are vital. "Thinking
about violence and playing about violence is not the same thing as
being violent. When we tell them not to pretend to shoot things, we
don't teach them not to do it, we teach them to lie." Fed up, one
teacher recently told me that she'd develop her own, post-post-
Columbine code: as long as everyone is laughing, then pretend shooting
is OK.
You can read her piece here.
More