Newsweek - National News, World News, Health, Technology, Entertainment and more... | Newsweek.com

Why It Matters

Full Post
Posted Wednesday, November 28, 2007 3:12 PM

France: Putting the ‘Riots’ in Perspective

Tracy McNicoll

In France this week, we’ve seen a local story spread round the world in flaming images. On Sunday, two teenage boys in the impoverished Parisian suburb of Villiers-le-Bel were killed when the small motorbike they were riding collided with a police car. The incident sparked local riots among youth who blamed police for the teens’ deaths. (An official investigation into the collision is ongoing.)

Whatever the real cause of the accident, it evoked echoes of the national riots that spread across almost 300 similarly economically depressed towns and suburbs throughout the country-and fears that something similar could happen again.  Back in October 2005, two teenage boys were electrocuted when they sought refuge from police in a power sub-station in Clichy-sous-Bois, another downscale suburb of Paris with large minority populations. That incident resulted in 10,000 torched cars and 300 torched buildings over three long weeks. The tough-talking Interior Minister in charge of law and order then, Nicolas Sarkozy, is now president.

This time, though, it seems to be different-at least so far. The two nights of fairly localized, if particularly violent, rioting this Sunday and Monday were indeed disturbing for authorities. They are a reminder that much still needs to be done to reconcile people living on the literal and figurative periphery of French society. And the fact that guns were fired at police, some of whom suffered injuries from buckshot, is a worrisome new development. No shots were fired during the riots of 2005. As then, no one was killed this week, but the use of weapons ratchets up the tension through protracted clashes and the increased risk of a violent police overreaction. 

Advertisement

Yet there’s also a risk that overstating the importance of these riots, especially by categorizing them as a test for President Sarkozy, can become a self-fulfilling prophecy. Teenage boys in neglected suburbs may well be tempted to create spectacles for armies of cameras come to film their anger. A single burning car framed close-up, on television or in a web or print photo, is deceptively impressive. (The French still joke about how some global media treated the story of the riots in 2005. One international news channel’s map of France put major city names in the wrong places while graphically embellishing them with flames.)

Early this morning, global audiences may have read wire reports lamenting a “third night of rioting.” But that is misleading. Indeed, the same police union spokesman who early Tuesday fed headlines by deploring rioters’ “urban guerilla”-style use of firearms said today that “nothing too nasty” happened last night and that no new shots were fired. That 138 cars were burned across France last night is actually nothing extraordinary--that’s about the average for any night. Violence may flare-up again when the teens killed in Sunday’s collision are buried. Or even before that. Or after. But the media covering the riots have the same responsibility police peppered with buckshot do--to keep the violence in perspective.

You must be a registered user to comment.  Click here to register.  Already a user?  Click here to login.

Member Comments

Posted By: polartech (December 4, 2007 at 2:15 AM)

In response to underdog, You are comparing apples to oranges, The majority of the inmigrants to the U.S. are from fellow western nations where the people share the same traditions, religion and culture as the U.S.. The inmigration situation in the states is more akin to the time when southern europeans used to move to northern europe in search of better jobs.


Posted By: wijreddenhet (November 30, 2007 at 6:15 PM)

There is only one solution, Deport all of the individuals involved and their families plus anyone even remotely involved in the violence to their own countries. When in Rome do as the Romans and these kind of immigrants have no such intention. They are just waiting until they out breed all of Europe and use democracy as a weapon to take over not only France buy all of Europe. This of course will lead to a Balkans type situation. The west must act now while it still has the advantage. What are the French do when a suicide bombers start attacking on a regular basis. When is all of Europe going to wake up realize there is very little time left act before civil war erupts all over Europe.


Posted By: YODA60 (November 30, 2007 at 4:39 PM)

The problems confronting France, the UK, the Netherlands, and other former colonial powers are their chickens come home to roost. The greed and arrogance of the colonial powers of Europe were the seeds sewn. The harvest is bitterness, alienation of 'immigrant' communities, and the discrimination they face. One might assume that in their chess-game-like scramble for the resources and markets of their colonies any notion of future consequences were very far out of mind. In former colonial nations with significant 'immigrant' communities (composed largely of persons from their former colonies) we now see the rise of nationalist anti-immigration political parties whose spokespersons convenitnely omit any reference to these countries' historical authorship of their present distress. But, alas, this is all 'blood under the bridge", to quote Albee's Virginia Wolfe. Much of the legacy of colonialism is ugly.  Most of the ugliness has presented itself to the citizens of former colonies, titularly independent, economically dependent, and liable to interference from the former coloniziers (remember Patreice Lumumba?). That 'immigrant' comunities in France find the national slogan of 'liberte, equalite, fraternite' somewhat hollow as applied to them should usher the nation into serious soul searching -- to face the realities and attempt to address problems without resort to xenophobic exhortations and their likely consequnces.


 
The Peek
 
 
PROJECT GREEN
NWK Caption: At the Excel High School in Oakland, California a group of students, their teacher and members of community groups pose with air pollution monitors in front of a mural at the school.  July 26, 2008.       Left to Right:   Randy Colosky, a member of Global Community Monitor  wearing brown shirt ,Juan Hernandez, student (seated) ,   Ina Bendich, teacher Danyale Willingham,student in blue top).Elizabeth de Rham far right, member of the Rose Foundation.

Young pollution sleuths and community activists fight for healthier air.

Sponsored by
 
 
 
 
Sponsored by
 
 
 
loadingLoading Menu