Christopher Dickey
|
Feb 21, 2008 04:33 PM

French
President Nicolas Sarkozy, who has a genius for turning conciliation
into provocation and common sense into cause for resentment, outdid
himself recently when he proposed that fifth-graders identify
themselves with individual children killed in the Holocaust, in effect
adopting the memory of the dead.
The most widely read French news and opinion weekly, Le Nouvel Observateur, devoted several articles to the controversy in Thursday’s edition, including a petition
for the proposal to be withdrawn: "We decline to discuss the nobility
of the intentions, the good will and the level of spirituality that
gave rise to such a project," says the appeal. "But we already see the
effects of it and they are catastrophic. They divide communities --
even, and perhaps more so, the Jewish community."
For anyone
interested in questions of anti-Semitism, secularism and Sarkozy, it’s
worth taking a close look at what the magazine has to say. (The links
are to the articles in French.)
The main story, headlined “The Mistake,”
tells us that Sarkozy put forth his proposal without consulting any of
his key ministers, much less preparing public opinion. (The latest
polls show that 85 percent of the French oppose the idea.) The report lays out “the story of a personal initiative that turned against the cause it was supposed to serve.”
Sarkozy
announced his plan at the annual dinner of the Representative Council
of Jewish Institutions in France (CRIF), where he was seated next to
Simone Veil, who is among other things a survivor of
Auschwitz-Birkenau, a former cabinet minister and the honorary
president of the Foundation for Remembrance of the Shoah. She held her
tongue during his remarks, but not afterward.
“It chilled my blood,” she said. “It’s inconceivable, unbearable,
over-dramatized and above all unfair. We can’t inflict that on
10-year-olds; we can’t ask a child to identify with a dead child. This
memory is too heavy to be borne.”
More