Christopher Dickey
|
Feb 28, 2008 09:15 AM
It's
hard to believe that anyone could long for the good old days of Jacques
Chirac, but when President Nicolas Sarkozy visited the Agriculture Fair
in Paris a few days ago, he managed to remind the French how
comfortable they used to feel with his lanky, laid-back predecessor.
When Chirac visited the annual fair, he did so as a bon vivant.
Sarkozy, on the other hand, went through it in an overheated rush,
using language fit for a scrum in the Metro. The video of the event
captured by the tabloid daily Le Parisien has been watched by more than three million viewers:
(You can see it with relevant translation on The Shadowland Journal .)
The climax comes when Sarkozy is shaking hands with the crowd and one
man pulls back, "Ah, no, don't touch me." Sarko, his fixed smile
unwavering says, "Get lost, then." To which the man responds, "You got
me dirty." To which Sarko responds (this is a polite way of putting
it), "Get lost, you jerk." The French don't like their
presidents to talk that way in public. (Chirac's language was plenty
salty in private.) But the real problem is that they're discovering
they just don't like Sarkozy. The cover story of this week's Le Nouvel Observateur explains why. In the lead article headlined "And if this were to end badly ... ,"
François Bazin writes that other presidents have been unpopular, but
for the most part late in their terms. When Chirac's ratings took a
nose dive in 1996, early in his first mandate, his prime minister,
Alain Juppé, took the fall. But Sarkozy wants all attention
fixed on him, and is managing to attract opprobrium to the office of
the president itself. "What's happening today is literally
unimaginable," writes Bazin. "In the current political
equation," he says, "there are plenty of other factors that enter into
to the bottom line. The international crisis that's sinking growth. A
campaign slogan ('Work more to earn more') that's remembered only too
well and that's come back like a boomerang. All that creates
turbulence, but doesn't justify the sense of an impending crash.The
mistake of the president, what has really cost him, goes much further
than management of change that's often contrarian and always marked by
traces of narcissism that are a bit childish. "The breaks with
past conceptions of a modern presidency that Sarkozy has introduced are
all symbolic in nature," writes Bazin. "His cardinal sin is to have
called into question, sometimes just with little details or simple
matters of behavior, that which legitimizes the authority of the head
of state in a country like France." One day he manages to diminish the
secular character of the French Republic (which is, to the French,
almost sacred). The next he tries to tweak the nation's conscience by
making 10-year-olds "adopt" victims their age killed in the Holocaust.
On yet another day, he undermines the institutional rules that regulate
the relationship a president has with his ministers, parliament, and
the constitutional council. "There's no such thing as good governance
without measure and distance," says Bazin. "And that presumes that the
head of state is something other than a gang leader you can collar and
talk to using he familiar 'tu.' And that also implies a certain
simplicity needed in the 'republican monarch' ... who should not be
transformed into a jet-setter fascinated by the glitz of power...." "At
the center of the rumbling political and media storm, the president has
chosen to expose himself more than is reasonable," Bazin concludes "
Every day he makes a statement that's offensive or provocative in some
way, radicalizing and shamelessly playing up to a disoriented public
opinion that just wants to feel secure. Dividing and victimizing. More
than a method, it's the formula of every man for himself. Nicolas
Sarkozy is out walking with a lightning rod in his hands. The risk for
him—and above all for the office that he holds—is that the
thunderbolts will not come from the presidency but land on it, which is
not at all the same thing."
More