Newsweek - National News, World News, Health, Technology, Entertainment and more... | Newsweek.com
Full Post
Posted Monday, October 20, 2008 4:56 PM

The Many Ways That Palin Has Hurt McCain

Howard Fineman

Gov. Sarah Palin's future is secure. She's a genuine grass-roots sensation and will remain one. Too bad that John McCain, the man who made her a star, isn't prospering with her. In fact, despite her nice turn on "Saturday Night Live," she has turned toxic for the McCain camp.

Palin's cheery good looks--and her gun-toting, Bible-thumping small-town conservatism--electrified the Republican convention and temporarily transfixed the "mainstream" media.

But her drawbacks have become painfully clear. For a variety of reasons, she has sent wavering Democrats, independents and moderate Republicans scurrying to Sen. Barack Obama--even as she has failed to substantially expand Sen. John McCain's support, even among the ranks of self-described  conservatives.

Advertisement

She was a huge asset for one pol, though: Barack Obama. A top Chicago fundraiser for Sen. Barack Obama tells me that Palin's selection as the GOP's vice presidential candidate was a  leading reason why Obama raised an astounding $150 million in September--more than double the previous campaign record. According to this source (a member of the financial inner circle; hence the insistence on anonymity), Obama got that boost because wavering donors were frightened into Obama's arms primarily by Palin's cultural conservatism on issues such as abortion and the teaching of evolution.

Three categories of donors opened their wallets for Obama in September: moderate Republicans; Jewish donors skeptical of Obama's commitment to Israel; and former "PUMAs"--hard-core Hillary Clinton supporters ("Party Unity My Ass). "Palin scared them," my source said, "and they put aside their doubts and resentments."

In the eyes of establishment figures--no matter what their ideology--Palin was a disaster. Leaders and opinion-shapers from Gen. Colin Powell to author Christopher Buckley to pundit-Reageanite Peggy Noonan called McCain's pick a cynical and irresponsible one--even if she had managed to sit still through one Henry Kissinger briefing. To these people, Palin's familiarity with dog-sled races did not make up for her utter lack of deep knowledge or worldly experience.

And for all of her defiant populist rhetoric--perhaps in part because of it--Palin has not unified the conservative movement behind McCain. That may have been too tall an order even for an Alaskan, but she hasn't done it. According to the IBD poll, only two thirds of self-described conservatives are backing McCain. Intentionally or not, Palin's stark and strident approach may be hurting McCain with the hard-right by vividly reminding them of what they expect a real conservative to sound like. This week she broke with her ticketmate to say that she favors a constitutional amendment banning gay marriage. In moments like these, her ideological certainty makes him look soft. 

Even if the other third of conservatives were watching "SNL," and liked what they saw, that would not be enough to turn this presidential race around.

You must be a registered user to comment.  Click here to register.  Already a user?  Click here to login.

Member Comments

Posted By: dgwv (November 4, 2008 at 11:20 AM)

People do not care what Obama pays for his clothers for two reasons.  First is that he pays for them himself.  Secondly, he does not make a big production of being a "common" person.  Palin's case is that she is an average "Joe" and that we should vote for her as such.   She likes to reinforce her averageness not only be her "common" lifestyle but by her "common" intelligence, which comes across as subcommon.   I find it amazing that people would like to be able to say that they are more intelligent than their Vice President.


Posted By: earth3650yahoo (October 30, 2008 at 12:54 AM)

Really and truly, Palin is highly over-rated.  Most mothers would offer the same temperament, the same open disposition and the same concern...in having this kind of opportunity.

Now, Ms. Palin thinks she is special.  John McCain has reinforced that.  In truth, most executive secretaries could and would be able to accomplish what she has accomplished.  But she is far from qualified for the responsibilities that may lie waiting when serving as under-study to a man of over 70 years old...a man who wants to find comfort in Arizona and maybe fish a lot.

I for one (a female), am insulted that someone so new and inexperienced would even begin to be compared to (or mentioned in the same paragraph) women who have much more education and knowledge...like Hillary Clinton.  But that is where the media has taken this allegedly divine 'average' woman named Palin.  She is not qualified, not qualified, not qualified.


Posted By: caraprado (October 27, 2008 at 12:11 AM)

From:

Head of State

http://headofstate.blogspot.com/2008/10/maverick-personality-disorder.html

Sunday, October 26, 2008

Maverick Personality Disorder

Palin may reject complicated scientific definitions.

Despite this, McCain and Palin have managed to make a contribution to the scientific literature.

Before this campaign, the term "maverick" was used loosely, imprecisely.

Now, on the basis of extensive behavioral observations and study, we can firmly say what a "maverick" actually is.

It's a personality disorder:

Maverick Personality Disorder 400.00 (Cluster B)

Maverick Personality Disorder is defined by a tendency to make rash, impulsive decisions that are regarded as both bold and correct--even if the decision directly contradicts another "bold" and "correct" decision that has been made only moments before. This impulsivity is to be distinguished from that seen in Borderline Personality Disorder in that in the latter disorder, self-destructive behavior is overt and intentional, whereas in Maverick Personality Disorder, the impulsive behavior is largely self-destructive, but the individual is rarely aware of it, instead thinking that they are acting "from their gut" in a reasonable fashion.

Sharp mood swings, dramatic gestures, and statements that reflect poor judgment and at times reduced perception of reality (e.g. "the fundamentals of the economy are sound") often occur in the disorder.

A. Three of the following symptoms, displayed in a persistent fashion over a period of 1 year, are necessary for the disorder:

a) Impulsive, rash thoughts and decision-making, often on matters of considerable long-term importance, the impact of which may have major deterimental effects on the individual or others. The impulsive decisions are often justified by such statements as being a "courageous thinker", and by disavowing thought and deliberation as negative characteristics. Notably, despite repeated negative outcomes of this impulsive decision making, the individual still maintains that this behavioral style is correct, and will become testy and irritable when challenged, or when reminded of previous negative outcomes. Ideas that are entirely at odds with each other may be seen concurrently, and such contradictions may be presented by the individual as entirely rational.

2) Dramatic, sweeping, impulsive and grandiose gestures that are meant to change a situation in its entirety, yet are often poorly thought through. The individual may present these acts as gallant and heroic, yet the individual often appears desperate, and provides only a paper-thin rationale for the efficacy of the actions.

3) Extreme mood swings or changes in affect, from apparently happy, to extreme anger and rage. Often these emotions will occur simultaneously, as in the "angry grimacing smile."

4) Binges, sprees or reckless/dangerous behavior without recognizing the potential consequences of such behavior, such as shopping sprees, entering interviews without knowledge of the subject at hand, or naming Vice Presidential candidates without sufficient vetting.

5) "Going Rogue": The tendency to stray from previous professional, social and personal commitments in an effort to protect the self.

6) Dissociative Speech Disturbances: The marked tendency to speak for extensive period of time without any apparent linkage between speech centers and centers of actual thought. The individual may appear entirely confident in what they are saying, speaking at length without pause, without displaying any deliberation, cerebration, contemplation or any other forms of thought whatsoever. With these speech disturbances may occur various accompanying behaviors, such as winking, thumb-raising, etc.

7) Dissociative Changes in Ideation: The individual may disavow major aspects of what they claimed to be the center of their beliefs--e.g., the viability of major tax cuts for the wealthy.

8) Verbal Echolalia: The seemingly uncontrollable repetition of certain words and phrases, even when they appear to have ritualistic meaning or have little or no purpose, remaining utility, or underlying truth. E.g., "My friends", "Socialist", "Joe the Plumber".

B. These behaviors must cause marked impairment in one's professional activities or campaign, and are obsessively maintained even when their destructive impact is clear.

C. These behaviors cannot occur exclusively during a period of Bipolar/Manic Depressive Illness, Major Depression, or political inactivity.

Codes for severity:

MPD Mild 400.01: Mutters to self and wanders grumpily during debate; threatens to attack Russia because it is in view;

MPD Moderate 400.02: Races to "save economy" that he claims is fundamentally sound; Appeals to others as "Average Mom", then wears $150,000 in wardrobe and makeup;

MPD Severe 400.03: Invokes "Joe the Plumber" despite long past sell-by date; Sits down in interview with Katie Couric.

Cite:

Head of State

http://headofstate.blogspot.com/2008/10/maverick-personality-disorder.html