By Mark Starr
Among the most conspicuous blessings of the holiday festivities was, of course, the gluttony--of the football variety. I watched all or parts of 19 games, seven NFL and 12 college, on television and capped my weekend by actually getting off my butt and out to the surprising Patriots-Eagles contest. No surprise here, though, I came away with a few football observations.
1) I suspect I’m in a minority, especially after the triple and quadruple overtimes in which Arkansas beat LSU to knock the Tigers out of the BCS Championship race and Tennessee nipped Kentucky to reach the SEC Championship game. Still, it confirmed for me that I don't like the college overtime system. It is not only distended, but is an entirely different game within a game--not unlike the dreaded shootouts to settle soccer championships. By giving each team the ball, it is supposed to eliminate the unfairness of the random coin flip that seems to dictate the results of NFL overtimes. But it still gives a huge advantage to the team that gets the ball second, allowing them to do whatever is necessary to win or tie. Throughout the years, the advantage of getting the ball first in the NFL has proved to be, at most, slight. (Sunday the two overtimes split: Chicago got the ovetime kickoff and marched down the field to score, but Arizona got the kickoff and coughed up the ball for a loss.) I would tweak the NFL rule one way. Skip the coin flip. Give the visiting team the ball first, a bonus for earning the tie on the road. Sudden death is great. College overtime, by contrast, is a slow death.
2) I have already ranted this season about the decline of the Big Ten and celebrated Ohio State's exodus from the BCS Championship game. Clearly the latter was premature Now, thanks to the chaos that is today's college football, Ohio State is miraculously back in contention--just needing a Missouri or West Virginia loss against Oklahoma and Pitt respectively in their final games this weekend. My issue, of course, was less with Oho State than with the other conference teams they beat to ascend so high in the rankings. So I wouldn't be surprised if Ohio State emerges as the betting favorite if they reach the championship game. Still, I'd much prefer to see an old-fashioned Ohio State-USC/Big Ten-Pac 10 showdown in the Rose Bowl. And if the Buckeyes whip the Trojans, everybody who wrote me angry notes can do it again--this time with the clear upper hand.
3) I don't want to dump on Andy Reid, whose off-field woes remind us of the NFL's relatively meaningless stakes. Nor am I a Donovan McNabb basher. Got to admire a man who became an Eagle to boos (when the Philly faithful hoped the team would draft Ricky Williams instead) and has played with grit before the league's harshest fans for nine seasons now. But it seems to me apparent that the Eagles don't need a superstar playmaker at the helm, if McNabb can even be called that any more, but rather somebody who'll run the offense, get the ball into the hands of Brian Westbrook frequently and get his passes off quickly and accurately. As far back as 2002, A.J. Feeley, then the third-string quarterback for the Eagles, started the last five games of the season and went 4-1. Last year, it was Jeff Garcia, subbing for an injured McNabb, who lifted the Eagles into the playoffs.. And this season, Feeley has stepped up again, rescuing a sputtering offense after McNabb was hurt against Miami, then almost leading the Eagles to the upset of the season against the Pats. Philly thrives, behind that huge offensive line, with a quarterback who can run Reid's version of the West Coast offense. Maybe McNabb can find rejuvenation elsewhere as Steve McNair did last season with the Baltimore Ravens. But it's clearly time for Reid to commit to change.
4) The Pats barely escaped the Eagles last night, reminding us how difficult it will be for New England to replicate the '72 Dolphins undefeated championship season. There have already been a slew of comparisons between the two teams. Truth is there is no valid comparison. Not only are today's teams constrained by the salary cap, but the NFL player today is a different species--check out the size of the respective offensive lines of the two teams 35 years apart--and they are, thanks to rule changes, playing an entirely different game as well. The '72 Dolphins, with three super running backs (Csonka, Morris and Kiick) ran the ball 613 times and threw just 259 or about 33 percent of the time. Hall-of-Famer Paul Warfield was the leading receiver for the season with 29 receptions. That Dolphins passing total is a few Sundays work for Brady and the Patriots Last night, the Patriots barely ran the ball at all--and if you eliminate Brady's three scrambles, Maroney's three run-out-the-clock plays and two goal line rushes for TDS, the Pats put the ball on the ground just eight times while putting up 54 passes. The Eagles were only slightly more balanced, with 42 passes and 19 runs. If it's still true that you've got to run to set up the pass, somebody should remind Coach Belichick.
5) I found most of the TV game calls and commentary during my marathon football weekend perfectly serviceable. But I can't say I remember a single thing that was said, not a moment of revelatory analysis or soaring elegance. Certainly nothing to rival the pithy, funny and poignant commentary that I encountered last week while following the England-Croatia soccer classic on ESPN.com Gamecast. Football or baseball on Gamecast are rather minimalist affairs--strike one, pass to Moss for 10 yards etc. But soccer, with so little linear action, provides a different kind of forum. As the soccer game at Wembley wound down to the final three, desperate minutes, with England trailing 3-2 and needing a tie to advance to the European championships, the commentator summed it all up perfectly in minimalist fashion. Just eleven words: "One goal to save a nation's dream and one man's job."