David Yepsen, the chief political writer and columnist for the Des
Moines Register, has the words "Dean of the Iowa Political Press Corps"
permanently affixed to his name, so I don't doubt that he's a bright
fellow who's forgotten more than Stumper will ever know about caucus
arithmetic and arcana.
That said, his crusade against Barack
Obama's aggressive campaign to turn out non-Iowans who attend college
in Iowa--even if they'll be home for winter break on Jan. 3--strikes me as sort of silly.
It started on Nov. 30 with a column called "The Illinois Caucus."
"These are the Iowa caucuses," he wrote. "Asking people
who are 'not from Iowa' to participate in them changes the nature of
the event." (Obama had recently released a four-page
"Students for Barack Obama" brochure that said “if you are
not from Iowa, you can come back for the Iowa caucus.") On Dec. 3, Yepsen told other reporters, including NBC's Aswini Anburajan, that Obama's collegiate push was "politically dumb." Now, Yepsen's latest column expands on that observation. "Obama... has built an impressive organization
and can win this on the legit," he writes. "He doesn't need to give opposition
spinners a way to discredit a victory." Cue a breathless "Yepsen Warns Obama Again" headline at The Page, Time's CW clearinghouse, and a buzzy items on the blogs.
Reading
Yepsen's collected works on the subject, it's difficult to discern what
he finds so offensive about Obama's effort. It's not illegal for
out-of-state students to caucus--Yepsen himself admits "its all quite
legal." (In fact, it's encouraged by
the Iowa Secretary of State.) And Obama isn't the only candidate
targeting out-of-state undergrads--Yepsen confesses that "other
campaigns
are signing up
nonresident Iowa college students, too." Yepsen does say that "no
presidential campaign in memory
has ever made such a large, open attempt to encourage students from
another state to participate in Iowa's caucuses," but I'm not sure you
can fault Obama for going "large" and "open" with an effort that Yepsen
agrees is both legal and nonexclusive. And unless "the Dean" is
accusing Obama of voter fraud, his insinuations about corrupt Illinois
politics--"they do elections a little differently in Illinois than we
do in Iowa"--are completely irrelevant.
Simply
put, all of Yepsen's sound and fury boils down to one weird argument:
it's
illegitimate (if "barely legal") for the 21,000 out-of-state Iowa
students to caucus. These are the same students, mind you, who live at
least
nine months a year for four to six years at a time in Iowa, where they
pay sales tax on every purchase and income tax on the money they earn
working part-time jobs--all while their fellow undergrads in, say,
Indiana register and vote in their newly adopted state without any
static.
But, you know, the Iowa caucuses
are for Iowans. The rest of the Hawkeye State's students should sit on the
presidential sidelines from the time they're old enough to vote until
long after they're old enough to drink, right? Isn't that what XBoxes are for?
As I said, silly. And sad, too. Obama's rivals--including Clinton and Dodd--have
already jumped on the nativist, ageist Yepsen bandwagon, and his odd complaints (as a real,
live Iowa expert!) only serve to stoke the sort of spin he says he anticipates in the wake of an Obama victory.
I just hope the rest of us don't buy it.