Rana Foroohar
|
Jul 16, 2009 11:01 AM
Could the next bubbles already be brewing, this early in a recovery? That’s what a number of sources I speak with have been saying in the past few weeks. Economists are worried about the price of oil, minerals, and other commodities─even though they’ve taken a slight dip in the past few days, they are still at prices far higher than usual at this point in the economic cycle. Ditto U.S. and European stocks, and especially emerging-market equities, which are really booming as everyone continues to dream of the days of double-digit returns. Even real estate is spiking again in places like China, Hong Kong, and a handful of other big cities in developing countries.
What’s driving this? An excess of spare cash around the world. Despite the downturn, there are still plenty of people holding lots of money on the sidelines, and they are itching to find a place to put it. If I had to pick the most worrisome bubble of the moment, I’d probably look east to China. Since last December, Chinese banks have given close to a trillion dollars in loans to help companies expand (year-on-year lending was up an unbelievable 1,000 percent at the start of this year). When I was in China in May, even bankers at state- run institutions were starting to worry that not all of this money was making its way into the real economy, and that much of it was being recycled into the stock markets and housing, possibly setting the stage for the next big painful bubbles there.
Policymakers in China and elsewhere are
going to be reluctant to take any action around brewing bubbles right now,
because the recovery isn’t yet entrenched. This is worrisome, because it could
set the stage for yet another boom-bust cycle (more on that in a future cover
story from our Morgan Stanley columnist, Ruchir Sharma). I wonder when we
might once again enter the period that Goldman Sachs chief economist Jim
O’Neill calls “the Twilight Zone”─a delicate time between boom and bust. This
is when “the economic fundamentals that support a boom begin to break apart, but
a future bust also becomes more likely.” This period must be managed with care
by politicians. Tomorrow, I’ll blog more on the Twilight Zone and how we might
make our way out of it unscathed in the future.